Lyell and the Principles of Geology

M. J. S. Rudwick
Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 143, 1-15, 1 January 1998, https://doi.org/10.1144/GSL.SP.1998.143.01.02

Abstract

Lyell’s Principles of Geology is still treated more often as an icon to be revered than as the embodiment of a complex scientific argument rooted in its own time and place. This paper describes briefly the origins of Lyell’s project, in the international geological debates of the 1820s and in his own early research; the structure of argument of the first edition (1830–1833), and its relation to its intended readership; and the modification of the work in subsequent editions, and the transformation of its strategy in response to its critical evaluation by other geologists. The fluidity of the Principles (and its offshoot the Elements of Geology) reflects the ever-changing interaction between Lyell and his fellow geologists, and between them and a much wider public, during one of the most creative periods in the history of geological science. Lyell’s scientific stature is best appreciated if he is placed not on a pedestal but among his peers, in debates at the Geological Society and elsewhere.

References

    1. Bartholomew M.
    (1973) Lyell and evolution: an account of Lyell’s response to the prospect of an evolutionary ancestry for Man. British Journal for the History of Science 6:261–303.
    OpenUrlPubMedWeb of Science
    1. Bartholomew M.
    (1976) The non-progression of non-progression: two responses to Lyell’s doctrine. British Journal for the History of Science 9:166–174.
    OpenUrlWeb of Science
    1. Bartholomew M.
    (1979) The singularity of Lyell. History of Science 17:276–293.
    OpenUrlCrossRef
    1. Bork K. B.
    (1990) Constant Prévost (1787–1856): the life and contributions of a French uniformitarian. Journal of Geological Education 38:21–27.
    OpenUrl
    1. Brocchi G.-B.
    (1814) Conchiologia fossile subapennina con osservazione geologiche sugli Apennini e sul suolo adiacente (Stamperia Reale, Milano) 2 vols.
    1. Buckland W.
    (1820) Vindiciae geologicae; or the connexion of geology with religion explained, in an inaugural lecture (W. Buckland, Oxford).
    1. Buckland W.
    (1822) Account of an assemblage of fossil teeth and bones belonging to extinct species of elephant, rhinceros, hippopotamus, and hyaena, and some animals discovered in a cave at Kirkdale, near Kirkby Moorside, Yorkshire. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 122:171–236.
    OpenUrl
    1. Buckland W.
    (1823) Reliquiae diluvianae; or, observations on the organic remains contained in caves, fissures, and diluvial gravel, and on other geological phenomena, attesting to the action of an universal deluge (Murray, London).
    1. Buffon G. de
    (1778) in Histoire naturelle, Des époques de la nature, ed Buffon G. de. (Imprimérie royale, Paris), Supplément 5, pp 1–254.
    1. Bynum W. F.
    (1984) Charles Lyell’s Antiquity of Man and its critics. Journal of the History of Biology 17:153–187.
    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
    1. Coleman W.
    (1962) Lyell and the “reality” of species, 1830–1833. Isis 53:325–338.
    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
    1. Corsi P.
    (1978) The importance of French transformist ideas for the second volume of Lyell’s Principles of Geology. British Journal for the History of Science 11:221–244.
    OpenUrlWeb of Science
    1. Cuvier G.
    (1812) Recherches sur les ossemens fossiles de quadrupèdes, où l’on rétablit les caractères de plusieurs espèces d’animaux que les révolutions du globe paroissent avoir détruites (Déterville, Paris) 4 vols.
    1. Cuvier G.,
    2. Brongniart A.
    (1811) Essai sur la géographie miné ralogique des environs de Paris. Mémoires de la Classe des Sciences Mathématiques et Physiques de l’Institut Impérial de France, 1–278, vol. for 1810.
    1. Darwin C.
    (1859) On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life (Murray, London).
    1. De la Beche H. T.
    (1834) Researches in Theoretical Geology (Knight, London).
    1. Desmond A.
    (1989) The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine, and Reform in Radical London (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
    1. Gould S. J.
    (1987) Time’s Arrow, Time’s Cycle (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
    1. Hall J.
    (1814) On the revolutions of the Earth’s surface. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 7:139–211.
    OpenUrl
    1. Hamm E. P.
    (1993) Bureaucratic Statistik or actualism? K. E. A. von Hoff’s History and the history of geology. History of Science 31:151–176.
    OpenUrlCrossRef
    1. Hoff K. E. A. von
    (1822–1834) Geschichte der durch Überlieferung nachgewiesenen natürlichen Veränderungen der Erdoberfläche: ein Versuch (Perthes, Gotha) 3 vols.
    1. Horner L.
    (1816) Conchiologia fossile Subapennina… di G. Brocchi, Milano, 1814. Edinburgh Review 26:156–180, Review of.
    OpenUrl
    1. Humboldt A. von
    (1817) Des lignes isothermes et de la distribution de la chaleur sur le globe. Mémoires de la physique et de la chimie de la Société d’Arceuil 3:462–602.
    OpenUrl
    1. Hutton J.
    (1788) Theory of the Earth; or an investigation of the laws observable in the composition, dissolution and restoration of the land upon the globe. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1:209–304.
    OpenUrlCrossRef
    1. Hutton J.
    (1795) Theory of the Earth, with Proofs and Illustrations (Creech, Edinburgh) 2 vols.
    1. Jorio A. de
    (1820) Ricerche sul Tempio di Serapide, in Puzzuoli (Società Filomatica, Napoli).
    1. Laudan R.
    (1982) The role of methodology in Lyell’s science. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 13:215–249.
    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
    1. Laudan R.
    (1987) From Mineralogy to Geology: The Foundations of a Science, 1650–1830 (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
    1. Lyell C.
    (1826) On a recent formation of freshwater limestone in Forfarshire, and on some recent deposits of freshwater marl. Transactions of the Geological Society of London 2:72–96. 2nd ser..
    OpenUrl
    1. Lyell C.
    (1827) Memoir on the geology of central France, including the volcanic formations of Auvergne, the Velay, and the Vivarrais, by G.P. Scrope, London. 1827. Quarterly Review 36:437–483, Review of.
    OpenUrl
    1. Lyell C.
    (1830–1833) Principles of Geology, Being an Attempt to Explain the Former Changes of the Earth’s Surface, by Reference to Causes Now in Operation (Murray, London) 3 vols.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1834) Principles of Geology, Being an Inquiry How Far the Former Changes of the Earth’s Surface are Referable to Causes Now in Operation (Murray, London) 4 vols, 3rd edn.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1838) Elements of Geology (Murray, London).
    1. Lyell C.
    (1840) Principles of Geology, or, the Modern Changes of the Earth and Its Inhabitants Considered as Illustrative of Geology (Murray, London) 3 vols, 6th edn.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1841) Elements of Geology (Murray, London) 2 vols, 2nd edn.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1863) The Geological Evidences of the Antiquity of Man with Remarks on Theories of the Origin of Species by Variation (Murray, London).
    1. Lyell C.
    (1868) Principles of geology, or, the modern changes of the Earth and its inhabitants considered as illustrative of geology (Murray, London) 2 vols, 10th edn.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1881) in Life Letters and Journals of Sir Charles Lyell, Bart, ed Lyell K. (Murray, London) 2 vols.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1990–1991) Principles of Geology (University of Chicago Press, Chicago) 3 vols, Facsimile reprint of 1st edn.
    1. Lyell C.
    (1997) Principles of Geology (Penguin, London), abridged from 1st edn.
    1. McCartney P. J.
    (1976) Charles Lyell and G.B. Brocchi: a study in comparative historiography. British Journal for the History of Science 9:177–189.
    OpenUrl
    1. Marini P.
    , ed (1987) L’opera scientifica di Giambattista Brocchi (1772–1826) (Città di Bassano del Grappa).
    1. Morrell J. B.
    (1976) London institutions and Lyell’s career, 1820–41. British Journal for the History of Science 9:132–146.
    OpenUrlWeb of Science
    1. Ospovat D.
    (1977) Lyell’s theory of climate. Journal of the History of Biology 10:317–339.
    OpenUrlCrossRef
    1. Playfair J.
    (1802) Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth (Creech, Edinburgh).
    1. Porter R.
    (1976) Charles Lyell and the principles of the history of geology. British Journal for the History of Science 9:91–103.
    OpenUrlWeb of Science
    1. Porter R.
    (1982) Charles Lyell: the public and private faces of science. Janus 69:29–50.
    OpenUrl
    1. Roger J.
    (1989) Buffon: un philosophe au Jardin du Roi (Fayard, Paris).
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1969) in Toward a History of Geology, Lyell on Etna, and the antiquity of the Earth, ed Schneer C. J. (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA), pp 288–304.
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1971) in Perspectives in the History of Science and Technology, Uniformity and progression: reflections on the structure of geological theory in the age of Lyell, ed Roller D. H. D. (Oklahoma University Press, Norman, OK).
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1974) Poulett Scrope on the volcanoes of Auvergne: Lyellian time and political economy. British Journal for the History of Science 7:205–242.
    OpenUrl
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1975) Caricature as a source for the history of science: De la Beche’s anti-Lyellian sketches of 1831. Isis 66:534–560.
    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1977) Historical analogies in the early geological work of Charles Lyell. Janus 64:89–107.
    OpenUrl
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1978) Charles Lyell’s dream of a statistical palaeontology. Palaeontology 21:225–244.
    OpenUrl
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1985) The Great Devonian Controversy: The Shaping of Scientific Knowledge among Gentlemanly Specialists (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1990–1991) in Principles of Geology, Introduction [and] Bibliography of Lyell’s sources, ed Lyell C. (University of Chicago Press, Chicago) vol. 3, Appendices, 133-160. Facsimile reprint, 1, pp vii–lxviii.
    OpenUrl
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1992) Scenes from Deep Time: Early Pictorial Representations of the Prehistoric World (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1996) Cuvier and Brongniart, William Smith, and the reconstruction of geohistory. Earth Sciences History 15:25–36.
    OpenUrl
    1. Rudwick M. J. S.
    (1997) Georges Cuvier, Fossil Bones, and Geological Catastrophes: New Translations and Interpretations of the Primary Texts (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
    1. Rupke N. A.
    (1983) The Great Chain of History: William Buckland and the English School of Geology (1814–1849) (Clarendon, Oxford).
    1. Scrope G. P.
    (1825) Considerations on Volcanos… Leading to the Establishment of a New Theory of the Earth (Phillips, London).
    1. Scrope G. P.
    (1827) Memoir on the Geology of Central France, Including the Volcanic Formations of Auvergne, the Velay and the Vivarrais (Longman, London) 2 vols.
    1. Scrope G. P.
    (1830) Principles of Geology by Charles Lyell, London, 1830. Quarterly Review 43:411–469, Review of.
    OpenUrl
    1. Secord J. A.
    (1986) Controversy in Victorian Geology: the Cambrian-Silurian Dispute (Princeton University Press, Princeton).
    1. Secord J. A.
    (1997) in Principles of Geology, Introduction, ed Lyell C. (Penguin, London) abridged.
    1. Whewell W.
    (1832) Quarterly Review, Principles of Geology by Charles Lyell, vol. 2, London, 1832. Review of, 47, pp 103–132.
    OpenUrl
    1. Wilson L. G.
    , ed (1970) Sir Charles Lyell’s Scientific Journals on the Species Question (Yale University Press, New Haven).
    1. Wilson L. G.
    , ed (1972) Charles Lyell, the Years to 1841: The Revolution in Geology (Yale University Press, New Haven).
Back to top
Alerts
Citation tools
Permissions
View PDF
Email to
Bookmark this article

Related Articles

Similar Articles

Cited By...